• His daughter, Harriet, was widowed at the age of 22, when her husband, John Taylor (then sheriff of Winnebago county), was shot and killed by a youth he had arrested for stealing cattle.327

• Sheriff John Taylor was shot and killed while chasing an escaping prisoner.
He and a local constable had arrested two brothers they suspected of cattle rustling. Upon searching the men Sheriff Taylor discovered one of them was carrying pistol balls. When he asked for the pistol the man said he did not have one. As they reached the jail the suspects suddenly broke free and ran with the sheriff in pursuit. The man who had been carrying the pistol balls pulled out a hidden pistol and shot Sheriff Taylor, killing him.
The suspect was apprehended several moments later. He was convicted of murder and sentenced to death. On March 27, 1857, he was executed by hanging on the farm of the current sheriff in one of the last public executions held in the state.
Sheriff Taylor was survived by his wife and 18-month-old son.6251